The composition of menus has always been somewhat of an obsession of
mine: indeed, I'm sure there are many who think I can write a menu far better
than I can actually cook it. Getting the balance of descriptive prose right is a difficult thing: nobody
wants verbose menus with flowery terms that make grand promises that are not
delivered. Similarly, you should always write menus for customers and not for your own
ego, so I tend not to use terminology that invites questions such as 'what
actually IS that?’
The new style of listing single ingredients, also leaves me cold. Writing a
‘carte’ which is appealing, succinct and exciting is most definitely an art
form. So I have more than a little sympathy for the catering team at Pembroke College
in Cambridge, when I hear about complaints they received from their customers. It seems the esteemed students of the college - one of the oldest and richest
in Cambridge - object to being served Jamaican stew and Chinese chicken on the
basis that they're not authentic offerings and therefore misrepresent their
culture. The students from the college that sells itself as "a college of poets and
scientists, thinkers and players, who want to make a difference to the
world" clearly have too much time on their hands, which is par for the
course for almost every student I have ever encountered. Imagine working away in the kitchen, doing your level best to be creative and
innovative, only to be castigated in this manner. The effort that has gone into producing the much-maligned dish of cauliflower,
date and tofu tagine with Tunisian rice and coriander yogurt is not
inconsequential, but it was panned because the rice 'wasn't really Tunisian’.
I'd substitute it for the ubiquitous vegetable lasagna on the next menu.
Having said that, I have to agree that somehow food seems to sound more
appealing when presented by other nationalities. Crouqe monsieur is far more appetizing than a cheese and ham toastie,
choucroute has a ring to it that pickled cabbage will never have, see also
tartiflette versus cheese and potato pie, crème brulee against burnt custard.
You’d also choose pate de tete over pork cheese every day of the week.
Perhaps the gilded students would prefer their servants spent more time on the
marketing of the menu than on their cooking of it? That would make a difference
to the world. Though probably not for the better.
You Should Always Write Menus for Customers
Posted: 16th March 2017
Categories:
Current